Student A
- 12x + 5 = 15
- 22x = 15 + 5
- 32x = 20
- 4x = 10
A question about how we learn
Two students can reach the same wrong answer for completely different reasons.
So why teach them the same way?
Follow the workBoth begin here:
Both wrote x = 10. The equation gives x = 5.
Student A added 5 instead of subtracting it. Student B subtracted 5 correctly, then left the coefficient 2 in place. The same final answer hides two different steps to teach.
Choose the first line where the reasoning may have gone wrong.
2x + 5 = 15
2x = 15 + 5
2x = 20
x = 10
2x + 5 = 15
2x = 10
x = 10
Student A · Authored Worked Solution
Choose a line or show the explanation to inspect the reasoning.
One probe can suggest a pattern; it cannot prove a permanent trait.
So we asked one more question.
Diagnostic question
One answer is evidence, not a diagnosis.
Fix the idea, not just the answer.
First experiment
An early math-word-problem baseline. It does not yet test handwritten linear-equation diagnosis.
Don’t just find the mistake.
Ask why it happened.