A question about how we learn

Every answer
has a path.

2x + 5 = 15

Two students can reach the same wrong answer for completely different reasons.

SAME ANSWER. DIFFERENT MISTAKE.

So why teach them the same way?

Follow the work

Same answer.
Different work.

Both begin here:

2x + 5 = 15

Student A

  1. 12x + 5 = 15
  2. 22x = 15 + 5
  3. 32x = 20
  4. 4x = 10

Student B

  1. 12x + 5 = 15
  2. 22x = 10
  3. 3x = 10
  4. →x = 10

Both wrote x = 10. The equation gives x = 5.

Look closer at the two paths

Student A added 5 instead of subtracting it. Student B subtracted 5 correctly, then left the coefficient 2 in place. The same final answer hides two different steps to teach.

Something changed here.

Choose the first line where the reasoning may have gone wrong.

Two routes to the same answer

Student A

2x + 5 = 15

2x = 15 + 5

2x = 20

x = 10

Student B

2x + 5 = 15

2x = 10

x = 10

Student's working

Student A · Authored Worked Solution

    Click or navigate to a line to test your reading.
    See the step-by-step explanationAvailable after a guess or reveal

    What might have happened?

    Choose a line or show the explanation to inspect the reasoning.

    One probe can suggest a pattern; it cannot prove a permanent trait.

    Maybe it was just a slip.

    So we asked one more question.

    Try this one.

    Diagnostic question

    Solve for x: x + 3 = 8
    Choose an answer

    One answer is evidence, not a diagnosis.

    Fix the idea, not just the answer.

    First experiment

    So we tested the first part.

    An early math-word-problem baseline. It does not yet test handwritten linear-equation diagnosis.

    What we used.
    What we still need.

    This is only the beginning.

    Don’t just find the mistake.
    Ask why it happened.

    Better learning starts with why.
    Back to the first page ↑